Guess What? Ontario Car Insurance Premiums Still Haven't Been Lowered 15%

Toronto personal injury lawyer Albert Conforzi: If you've been reading my blog - but of course you have - then you'll know that I've been following this story for quite a while. Two years, in fact:

Auto insurance rates are down by an average of just under seven per cent in Ontario, much less than the 15 per cent reduction promised by Finance Minister Charles Sousa two years ago.

The latest figures from the Financial Services Commission of Ontario, released Thursday, show rates fell half a point in the quarter ended Sept. 30, to 6.96 per cent for the province’s 9.4 million drivers.

Sousa took credit for the drop, saying reforms to benefits, anti-fraud measures and mandatory discounts for motorists with winter tires have helped cut costs for drivers.
But he acknowledged “there is more work to be done.”

Critics said that line is wearing thin given that the Liberals pledged the 15 per cent cut to win NDP support of their 2013 budget during the minority government years.

As the story points out, this latest piece of news isn't exactly "new." We see the same type of story every six months or so. That is, the 2013 promise of a 15% reduction in car insurance premiums for Ontario drivers still hasn't happened.

Hold The Champagne

Celebration of rate reductions seems premature, anyway. Check out the fine print at the bottom of the article: "The third-quarter drop of 0.5 per cent compares with an average increase of 0.6 per cent in the second quarter." So it went up before it went down, making the past six months a wash.

Whatever happens with these slight rate fluctuations, rest assured that your benefits are decreasing. This is from a post I wrote a month back:

Starting on June 1, 2016, standard medical, rehabilitation and attendant care benefits will have a maximum combined limit of $65,000 for non-catastrophic cases. After that money is spent, you are on your own. Since September 2010, that limit has been $86,000. Before that it was $172,000.

While the cost of health care keeps rising and rising, the money available for your benefits keeps dropping and dropping. Further, as of June 2016, the coverage period will be cut in half from the current 10 years to a mere 5 years.

Perhaps it's worth phoning your MPP and asking when your 15% premium reductions will kick in to offset all of the benefits you'll be missing next year.

I am a personal injury lawyer with Pace Law Firm in Toronto. Contact me if you have any questions.

Insurance Companies Playing A Shell Game With Your Benefits

The benefits you will lose as of June 1, 2016.

Toronto personal injury lawyer Albert Coforzi: A couple of weeks ago I alerted readers to the coming changes to Ontario car insurance. The government of Ontario, in close collaboration with insurance companies, has planned these changes for motorists. You may recall the letter you received asking you to collaborate on something that will greatly affect your life. No? Alas, it's too bad you missed the memo.

Benefits gutted again

Starting on June 1, 2016, standard medical, rehabilitation and attendant care benefits will have a maximum combined limit of $65,000 for non-catastrophic cases. After that money is spent, you are on your own. Since September 2010, that limit has been $86,000. Before that it was $172,000.

While the cost of health care keeps rising and rising, the money available for your benefits keeps dropping and dropping. Further, as of June 2016, the coverage period will be cut in half from the current 10 years to a mere 5 years.

Now you see me. Now you don't.

It's not that the extra coverage isn't available. It's that you must now pay extra for it, as more of your benefits - and their duration - become "optional."

Insurance companies love the optional stuff. "Hey, we didn't remove coverage. We just wanted you to decide for yourself if you really need it." How would a regular consumer know that? Experience has shown me that these options are rarely purchased and most consumers do not know that they even exist, let alone that the coverage might change on some arbitrary future date.

Indeed, the average person who purchases car insurance does not know that their benefits are ever-changing. Ask five of your friends if any of them have heard that the standard benefits I listed above will be cut by over twenty grand next year. I'd be floored if any of them have.

From out of nowhere

That's part of the problem. Neither the insurance companies nor the government throw up red flags to warn consumers of car insurance changes. Well, sometimes a flag does go up, as when the government touts a plan to lower your car insurance premiums by 15%. Guess how that went?

I'll have more on the 2016 changes in the weeks ahead. In the meantime, it is worth looking at your car insurance policy and asking questions not only of your insurance representative, but also your MPP. Ask them how your policy will change next year and why. The answers may amuse you and frighten you in equal amounts.

I am a personal injury lawyer with Pace Law Firm in Toronto. Contact me if you have any questions.

Upcoming Changes To Accident Benefits: Insurance Companies Win Again

Toronto personal injury lawyer Albert Coforzi: The current government of Ontario, following in a long tradition of governments of every political stripe bending over backwards for the benefit of the insurance company lobby, has signaled changes to what constitutes a "catastrophic impairment." The changes come into effect on June 1, 2016.

Among the more egregious changes: the amputation of an arm as a result of a motor vehicle accident will be considered catastrophic while the amputation of a leg will not.

Missing leg? Not "catastrophic" enough

Under the current Statutory Accident Benefits regime, a person who has lost an arm or a leg has a million insurance dollars available for medical and rehabilitation benefits. This helps for such things as stump care and prosthetic limbs. The coming regime change will reduce that money available for a leg amputee as described in the regulation to $65,000 of combined coverage: medical/rehab plus attendant care.

If you've ever had $2000 worth of dental work for a root canal and crown, ask yourself how quickly 65 grand will go when you are recovering from a leg amputation and you need to learn how to use a prosthetic device.

Insurance industry wins another round

But hey, there's always someone available to pick up the short fall. Guess who that will be? Yes, the Ontario taxpayer. A careless motorist causes a victim to lose a leg and it's our healthcare system that will take on the financial burden of care and recovery, rather than an insurance company that actually plans for this type of event. Makes a lot of sense....to insurers, I bet.

I'll be posting more information on the insurance regime changes in the months ahead. Stay tuned.

I am a personal injury lawyer with Pace Law Firm in Toronto. Contact me if you have any questions.